Mistakes You Should Avoid When Buying a New Bike

When it comes to acquiring a new bicycle, there are several errors a new bike enthusiast like yourself might encounter that can be easily overlooked. This guide is designed to help navigate the common missteps individuals like you can make during this process and how you can easily overcome them. Insights and guidance were gathered through discussions with experienced professionals in the bike industry, and even from bike shops themselves, revealing prevalent misconceptions and errors surrounding bike purchases. Continuing forward, this guide aims to explore each of these errors in-depth, providing valuable information to help you avoid these common mistakes.

Continue reading to dive deeper into these common misconceptions that first-time bicycle buyers might encounter, and discover practical insights on how to avoid them. As you embark on your journey to find the perfect bike, it’s essential to be well-informed and equipped with the knowledge that will guide you to make a wise and satisfying decision. By understanding these errors and learning how to steer clear of them, you can navigate the process of purchasing your first bike with confidence and ensure that your cycling experience begins on the right pedal, so to speak.

Mistake 1: Miscalculating Bike Size:

Selecting the wrong bike size can significantly impact your experience as a first-time buyer. Riding a bike that doesn’t fit properly can lead to discomfort, affect your riding performance, and even increase the risk of potential injuries. Understanding the repercussions of an ill-fitting bike is crucial to avoid this common mistake.

To prevent choosing the wrong bike size, there are several steps you can take. First, rather than relying solely on height for sizing, consider other critical measurements like your inseam length. This additional information can guide you towards a more accurate frame size selection.

Furthermore, take advantage of resources such as bike size charts and guides specifically tailored for new riders like yourself. These tools often include bike size calculators, which can assist in making a more informed decision about the right bike size for you.

Additionally, never underestimate the value of a test ride. Trying out different bikes of various sizes and types allows you to feel the differences in fit, comfort, and handling. This hands-on experience is extremely helpful in finding the ideal bike size that suits you best. Almost all bike shops would happily offer you a free test ride with the bike you desire, so don’t be afraid to ask them to take one of them out for a spin.

Lastly, of course, if you have the necessary budget, consider investing in a professional bike fitting session. A professional can evaluate your body proportions, riding style, and personal comfort preferences, providing invaluable guidance to ensure the perfect match between you and your bike.

By considering these steps, you can avoid the mistake of selecting the wrong bike size as a first-time buyer. Knowing about these easy errors you could potentially make and avoiding them will enhance your riding experience, ensuring a comfortable, enjoyable, and safe journey on your new bike.

Bicycle Size Guide Chart:

Rider Height (inches/cm)Inseam Length (inches/cm)Recommended Frame Size (inches/cm)
4’10” – 5’1″ (147-155 cm)25″ – 27″ (63-69 cm)13″ – 15″ (33-38 cm)
5’1″ – 5’5″ (155-165 cm)27″ – 29″ (69-74 cm)15″ – 17″ (38-43 cm)
5’5″ – 5’9″ (165-175 cm)29″ – 31″ (74-79 cm)17″ – 19″ (43-48 cm)
5’9″ – 6’0″ (175-183 cm)31″ – 33″ (79-84 cm)19″ – 21″ (48-53 cm)
6’0″ – 6’3″ (183-191 cm)33″ – 35″ (84-89 cm)21″ – 23″ (53-58 cm)
6’3″ – 6’6″ (191-198 cm)35″ – 37″ (89-94 cm)23″ – 25″ (58-63 cm)

Note: This is a general guide. Individual preferences may vary. It’s recommended to test ride bikes and seek professional fitting advice for the best match.

Mistake 2: Inadequate Bike Type Selection

 Selecting a bike that doesn’t align with the intended terrain or riding style you want can lead to dissatisfaction in the long run. Understanding where you plan to ride and defining your riding style is vital.

The bike market offers a wide range of bicycle types with various subcategories, including hybrid bikes (for city, commuting, cruising), road bikes (for road, gravel, CX, TT), and mountain bikes (for XC, trail, enduro). An in-depth guide can help you navigate the differences and lead you in the direction of your preferences in the cycling world, however, these are some short points you could consider, which can help you choose which type of bike would satisfy your needs the most:

If you plan to primarily ride on smooth paved roads, a road bike might be your best option. Its lightweight design and sleek tires are optimized for speed, making it an ideal choice for long rides and fitness training. Opting for a road bike when you intend to ride mostly on paved surfaces means you’ll have a bike tailored for efficiency and speed, ensuring an enjoyable experience for your preferred road type.

Contrarily, if your riding adventures involve exploring rough terrains, such as mountain trails or off-road paths, a mountain bike is the better choice. Its robust frame, wider tires with rugged treads, and suspension systems are designed to handle bumpy, uneven surfaces. Choosing a mountain bike for such conditions will offer better stability, control, and comfort, enabling you to navigate through challenging landscapes with ease.

Hybrid bikes, blending features of road and mountain bikes, are versatile and suitable for various terrains. If you plan to ride both on roads and occasionally venture off-road, a hybrid bike could be an excellent compromise. Its adaptable nature ensures decent performance on different surfaces, making it a versatile option for your varied riding needs. However, you might find the maneuvering, speed, and efficiency of hybrid bikes perform worse than designated bikes. These bikes, most of the time, have to sacrifice some performance from both pavement roads and also rough terrains in order to be used in them both. You can’t have all of them!

Further considerations that should be taken into account besides the primary terrain would be, factors like suspension type, frame material, and gear ratios,  which should align with your riding preferences. For example, a mountain bike suitable for rough trails might require more suspension travel, a durable frame, and lower gear ratios compared to a road bike designed for speed on smooth surfaces, which would be less rigid, and have higher gear ratios.

Bike Type Selection Guide:

Terrain/Riding StyleRecommended Bike TypeFeatures and Considerations
Smooth Paved RoadsRoad Bike– Lightweight design optimized for speed
– Sleek tires for efficient riding on paved surfaces
– Ideal for long rides and fitness training
Rough Terrains/Off-road PathsMountain Bike– Robust frame and wider tires with rugged treads
– Suspension systems for handling bumpy, uneven surfaces
– Better stability, control, and comfort on challenging landscapes
Varied Terrains (Roads/Off-road)Hybrid Bike– Blends features of road and mountain bikes
– Versatile and suitable for various terrains
– Adaptable nature for decent performance on different surfaces
– Considerations: Maneuvering, speed, and efficiency may be compromised

Mistake 3: Forgetting Gear and Accessories:

Gear and accessories are an integral part of the overall cycling experience, often forgotten by first-time buyers focused solely on purchasing the bike. It’s important to understand that investing all your budget into the bike itself might leave you short on the essential gear and accessories required for a safe and comfortable ride.

Biking gear and accessories play a significant role in enhancing both safety and comfort during your rides. Helmets, for instance, are a critical safety item that should never be compromised. Investing in a high-quality, properly fitting helmet is vital to protect yourself in case of an accident. Cheaping out on or even forgetting to buy this essential piece of equipment would risk your safety and life on the road.

In addition to safety gear, there are various accessories that contribute to a more enjoyable and efficient riding experience. Items such as cycling gloves, padded shorts, and cycling shoes can significantly improve comfort during long rides. Other accessories like bike lights, a reliable lock, a repair kit, and a water bottle holder are essential for convenience, security, and hydration. 

Suppose you spend your entire budget solely on the bike without taking into account the necessary gear and accessories. In that case, you might find yourself without these vital components, compromising both your safety and the overall comfort of your rides.

Therefore, it’s crucial to allocate a portion of your budget for these necessary items. Consider finding a balance between the quality of the bike and purchasing the essential gear and accessories. Doing so ensures a safe, comfortable, and enjoyable cycling experience while making the most out of your investment in cycling.

Mistake 4: Buying Based Off the Price:

Buying a new bike involves finding the sweet spot between cost and quality, a critical consideration for beginners. Opting for the cheapest bike, while initially budget-friendly, often leads to a subpar cycling experience. These lower-cost bikes tend to compromise on essential factors impacting the ride quality, such as added weight, frequent need for adjustments, and overall lack of reliability, diminishing the joy of riding, which could lead to you falling out of love with your new hobby.

Conversely, investing in an expensive bike might seem like a gateway to guaranteed quality to you. However, the substantial upfront cost can strain your budget, leaving insufficient funds for essential accessories such as protective gear, comfortable cycling attire or general maintenance for the bike itself. Achieving the right balance between cost and quality is crucial. Bikes priced under $300 may serve the purpose for short rides but might lack the durability and features that enhance the overall cycling experience. Contrarily, bikes over $2000 might offer advanced features, but for first-time buyers, this might be an extravagant investment, especially without a clear understanding of your specific riding needs, and as mentioned before, can hinder your budget.

On the other hand, the second-hand bike market is very active and you can benefit from this cost-efficient way. Buying a second-hand bike has advantages of lower cost, wider model choices, and reduced depreciation, alongside environmental benefits. However, drawbacks include higher maintenance, uncertain history, lack of warranties, and limited selection. A comprehensive inspection and understanding of the bike’s history are crucial before you purchase one. In short, used bikes can be very advantageous but you should be extra cautious when planning on buying from the second-hand market.

Exploring the ideal price range necessitates a deeper understanding of personal requirements and the intended use of the bike. Buying a bike for the first time is not solely about the initial price tag but also about the overall value and long-term benefits a bike offers. This comprehensive analysis is fundamental for individuals like yourself to make informed decisions aligned with your cycling aspirations.

Mistake 5: Prioritizing Aesthetics over Technicalities and Components:

Choosing a bike solely based on appearance could lead to overlooking crucial technical aspects that impact the overall riding experience. While aesthetics are important, you should value functional components more.

When faced with a choice between two bikes with identical components, personal preferences might influence your selection. However, if one bike offers superior brakes, shifters, and derailleur at the same price point, it’s a wiser investment for you to make for a more satisfying ride over the years.

The significance of components in bikes often gets overlooked due to a lack of understanding. Providing comprehensive information is crucial to empower first-time buyers to make informed decisions. Efforts to offer valuable insights and knowledge to aid in these decisions are essential for informed purchases.

Opting for a bike with superior technical specifications at a similar price, compared to a more aesthetically pleasing but technically inferior bike, offers several advantages. High-quality components like brakes, shifters, and a well-designed frame contribute to better performance, durability, and reduced injury risk. Investing in these technical features ensures a more enjoyable ride, increased safety, and longer-lasting satisfaction compared to a bike prioritizing appearance over essential technical aspects.

Mistake 6: Falling into the “As Seen On TV” Trap:

The significance of independent research and personal experience when buying a bike cannot be overstated. Television commercials and online advertisements can often paint a highly appealing picture of a product, but the reality might not always match the promoted image. Therefore, taking the time and effort to conduct your own thorough research before making a purchasing decision is crucial as mentioned in the points above.

By avoiding the sole influence of advertisements and instead diving into independent exploration, you equip yourself with valuable knowledge to make a well-informed decision that aligns with your unique preferences and requirements. This independent research allows you to consider a range of factors beyond what’s depicted in advertisements, ensuring your chosen bike meets your specific needs, preferences, and riding style.

It’s quite common for first-time buyers to rely on online reviews, product appearance, and price when making a bike purchase. While these considerations hold some value, it’s highly recommended, particularly for new enthusiasts like yourself, to go a step further and physically test the bike before committing to the purchase like we’ve talked about in the first and second mistakes above. Engaging in a test ride, if possible, grants you hands-on experience and provides a real feel of how the bike performs on the road. Getting a sense of its handling, comfort, and overall ride quality is immensely beneficial in making a decision that guarantees your satisfaction with the chosen bike.

Hence, while advertisements and online information provide a starting point, relying solely on these sources might not provide a complete understanding of the bike’s suitability for your needs. Utilizing personal research and the invaluable experience gained from testing the bike firsthand ensures that your purchase aligns perfectly with your expectations, ultimately leading to a more satisfying and enjoyable cycling experience.

Also, keep in mind that while new deals and discounts can seem enticing, they might not always reflect the actual value or quality of a bike. Sometimes, deeply discounted bikes might lack the necessary components or have inferior build quality. Therefore, it’s crucial not to solely rely on these deals as they might compromise the overall performance and durability of the bike you intend to purchase; and also don’t immediately buy a bike just because it went on sale, research and test it out first to see if it meets your needs.

Mistake 7: Not Choosing the Right Material

When considering a bike’s material, it’s essential to recognize how different materials impact your riding experience and the bike’s fit. For instance, aluminum frames, known for their lightweight nature, can affect how the bike handles and responds to your movements. The inherent stiffness of aluminum might influence your comfort and shock absorption, potentially making you consider a slightly different frame size for the most comfortable ride.

On the other hand, carbon fiber frames offer versatility due to their ability to be engineered with varying levels of stiffness, compliance, and weight. These frames can influence your perception of the bike’s size suitability as they absorb vibrations differently, potentially altering your comfort and handling experience and potentially leading you to consider a different frame size for the best fit.

Steel frames, prized for their durability and comfortable ride quality, absorb more vibrations compared to aluminum. This characteristic might influence how you perceive the need for a specific frame size, particularly if you’re seeking a smoother, more comfortable ride, potentially prompting you to choose a different frame size for enhanced comfort.

Similarly, titanium frames offer a unique combination of durability, comfort, and lightweight properties. The compliance and shock-absorbing nature of titanium might impact your perception of the bike’s size, potentially leading you to consider an adjusted frame size for your optimum comfort level.

Understanding these distinctions in bike frame materials is very important for finding the right fit for you. Each material possesses unique characteristics that can impact your riding experience. 


Taking these potential missteps into account and avoiding them will greatly enhance your buying experience as a first-time bicycle purchaser. Recognizing the significance of accurately sizing your bike, avoiding aesthetics over technical performance, and comprehending the importance of appropriate material selection are key steps in securing a successful and satisfying purchase. Remember, allocating a portion of your budget for necessary accessories and gear, conducting thorough research, and being mindful of the balance between cost and quality will ensure a well-informed decision, ultimately leading to a safe, comfortable, and enjoyable cycling journey on your new bike. 

Leave a Reply